Hope In the Pews
What priests can do to foster this much-needed virtue in their parish
Father Mark Toups Comments Off on Hope In the Pews
We find ourselves living in a time characterized by profound political, cultural and ecclesial fragmentation. In recent decades, the deepening divisions have permeated nearly every aspect of human life, creating a landscape of discord that is hard to navigate. Our nation has become increasingly polarized — politically, socially and morally. Conversations that once thrived on constructive dialogue have eroded into shouting matches; the art of listening appears to have been abandoned. The nuances of complex discussions have given way to suspicion and even hostility. Regrettably, the Church, in many ways a microcosm of society, has not been immune to this troubling trend.
Within the Body of Christ, we have witnessed the rise of factions and camps, each claiming ownership of the truth while often failing to engage with those who hold differing perspectives. The terms “liberal” and “conservative,” which were once primarily political descriptors, have taken root in our Catholic discourse in ways that are detrimental to unity. Some parishes are labeled as “too traditional,” while others are deemed “too progressive,” creating an environment of suspicion and judgment. Even those in leadership — bishops and priests — are often scrutinized through narrow ideological or liturgical lenses. Trust has eroded, unity has frayed and many of the faithful are left wondering where they can turn for solace and guidance. Even those who remain devout carry a palpable spiritual exhaustion, having internalized the chaos and uncertainty of the world around them.
In this storm of division and despair, it is paramount that the priest steps forward, not as yet another commentator or combatant in these ideological battles, but as a beacon of hope. In a world that seems to be fraying at the seams, priests must be men who speak words of healing and restoration. In a Church that is struggling to find its unified voice, priests have a vital role in reminding the faithful of God’s unchanging fidelity and love. When fear becomes the prevailing atmosphere, it is the priest’s responsibility to breathe courage into the hearts of the parish. When despair whispers lies into the minds of the faithful, priests must boldly proclaim the promises of Christ, illuminating the path forward.
Hope is not an optional accessory for the priest; it is essential, intrinsically woven into the fabric of the priestly vocation. Without hope, ministry is reduced to mere maintenance, losing its transformative potential. Without hope, preaching can devolve into bland platitudes that fail to inspire or uplift. Without hope, the sacraments risk losing their prophetic dimension, becoming mere rituals to us.
Moreover, the priest must genuinely believe that God is still at work within the Church, that it remains his bride despite its imperfections, and that the Gospel continues to possess the power to bring new life into the hearts of believers. In fostering an atmosphere of hope, priests can help to heal the wounds of division and re-establish the bonds of unity that our Church so desperately needs today. As bearers of this hope, they can guide their communities toward a future rich in faith, love and understanding, rekindling the flame of solidarity amid a world marked by fragmentation. The call for hope is a call to courage, action and, above all, faith in God’s enduring promise.
Pope Francis, in Evangelii Gaudium (“The Joy of the Gospel”), wrote, “One of the more serious temptations which stifles boldness and zeal is a defeatism that turns us into disillusioned pessimists. … Nobody can go off to battle unless he is fully convinced of victory beforehand. If we start without confidence, we have already lost half the battle” (No. 85)
This dual vision — grounded realism combined with transcendent hope — is exactly what our age demands. It does not require an escape from darkness, but rather a defiant light shining within it. In this Jubilee Year of Hope, the Church offers us a renewed opportunity to reclaim that light. This essay proposes that priests can foster hope in their parishes in three ways: by being men of hope themselves, by providing their people with reasons to hope, and by using the homily as a consistent instrument of hope. But first, we must begin with the occasion that invites us into this conversation: the Jubilee.
A Season of Restoration and Hope
A jubilee year, deeply rooted in biblical tradition, represents a significant time of restoration, renewal and — most importantly — hope. Instituted in Chapter 25 of the Book of Leviticus, a jubilee was a sacred period in the life of Israel. During this time, practices such as releasing slaves, forgiving debts and returning land to its rightful owners were observed. It served as a radical reset for the community, a reminder that everything ultimately belongs to God and that he desires freedom and restoration for his people. A jubilee was not merely an economic or social event; it was a profound theological proclamation. It declared that God is faithful and consistently acts on behalf of his people, affirming a divine commitment to justice, mercy and wholeness.
In today’s world, many find themselves immersed in a reality overshadowed by anxiety, division, disillusionment and spiritual fatigue. These struggles are not confined to individuals but also manifest within the Church. In such a climate, the arrival of the Jubilee Year of Hope presents itself like a beacon — a clarion call to recalibrate our hearts and reawaken our vision to the undeniable truth that God is not finished with his Church or with his priests. The Jubilee Year invites us to reclaim our identity as a people of hope and encourages us to allow that hope to radiate outward, especially from our parishes.
For Christians, hope transcends mere sentiment; it is not simply naive optimism or a fleeting emotional lift. Rather, hope embodies the theological virtue by which we actively desire and trust in the promises of Christ. In a world that often ridicules that hope or misplaces it in lesser things, the priest is called to be a signpost of hope — a man whose life and ministry consistently reorient the faithful toward the One who will never fail. This calling becomes especially poignant in the Jubilee Year, as it presents priests with a unique opportunity to embody and bear hope to their congregations.

The question then arises: How can priests tangibly and consistently foster hope within parish life? First and foremost, it begins with being a man of hope himself. Second, giving people reasons to hope is crucial. Finally, preaching hope intentionally must be a priority. Homilies should be infused with themes of hope, focusing on the Resurrection and God’s eternal promises. Let us unpack these together.
Be a Man of Hope
Before a priest can offer hope to others, he must first possess it within himself. The role of a minister cannot sustain itself solely on the fumes of performance or the pressures of public expectation. For hope to be authentic and transformative, it must be deeply personal and rooted in a genuine relationship with God. This inner cultivation of hope is supported by three fundamental pillars: keeping your eyes on the Lord, choosing unity over division and surrounding oneself with hopeful priests.
1. Keep your eyes on the Lord: One of the most profound insights I have received was shared not by a theologian or a seasoned spiritual director but by a simple parishioner, who said, “Life is a lot less about what you’re facing and a lot more about where you’re looking.” At this time in history, it becomes increasingly vital to recognize that our gaze determines our grounding.
When our focus is centered on Christ, even during challenges, we find an anchor that provides stability and strength. This anchoring, however, requires more than mere obligatory prayer or a checklist of spiritual activities. It demands a deep and personal intimacy with the Lord. Beyond the structured prayers of the Liturgy of the Hours and the responsibilities inherent in sacramental duties, there must be an intentional space carved out for personal, relational prayer — a daily conversation with Jesus characterized by honesty, affection and persistence. Without this vital connection, the risks of burnout or bitterness loom large. However, with it, we remain rooted in the only One who grants lasting hope and sustains our spirits in times of adversity.
2. Choose unity over division: In today’s increasingly fragmented world, the spirit of polarization has unfortunately seeped into the Church. Labels such as “liberal,” “conservative,” “traditionalist” and “progressive” have begun to dominate not only ecclesial discourse but also personal identity. For a priest to embody the spirit of hope, he must rise above these false binaries that seek to divide and categorize.
Choosing unity cannot imply avoiding the truth or compromising core doctrines. Instead, it means resisting the temptation to let categories dictate our overall outlook. Hopeful priests actively seek communion in the Lord as a model of bridge-building in a world that is often characterized by walls and divisions. This way of living requires humility, self-awareness and a commitment to regular introspection. By intentionally rejecting the divisive spirit of our age, we create a space for seeing all things by the light of Christ, which then illuminates our paths.
3. Surround yourself with hopeful priests: The company we keep has an undeniable influence on our spiritual and emotional well-being. The fraternity we cultivate often determines the attitudes we adopt, for better or for worse. Negativity can easily become contagious; it can subtly infiltrate our thoughts and feelings, making it increasingly difficult to maintain hope. Conversely, surrounding ourselves with joyful and optimistic brothers in the priesthood can profoundly shape our own spirit in uplifting ways.
Thus, it is essential to audit our influences: Who is speaking into our lives as priests? Whom do we choose to vent to, share laughter with and engage in prayerful companionship? A hopeful heart is not born in isolation; instead, it thrives in the rich soil of communion with others. By deliberately seeking out relationships with fellow priests who exhibit a passion for their vocation and who embody a spirit of possibility, we begin to cultivate an environment where hope can flourish, encouraging us to rise above the challenges we face.
In conclusion, if a priest is to be a beacon of hope in his community, he must first nurture hope within himself through a constant focus on Christ, an unwavering commitment to unity, and a deliberate choice to cultivate relationships with fellow hopeful priests. This multifaceted approach not only enriches his spiritual life but also empowers him to extend that hope to those he serves, illuminating the path for others amid the darkness.
Give People Reasons for Hope
Hope is a fundamental aspect of the human experience, and it is particularly vital within the context of faith. The role of a priest extends beyond personal hope; it encompasses the crucial mission of awakening hope in others. For this to happen, individuals need tangible reasons to anchor their hope. Hope thrives on evidence; it is a living, dynamic aspect of faith that must be nurtured.
1. Help people see what God is doing: In many cases, hopelessness does not stem from despair, but rather from a state of apathy or forgetfulness. Individuals may become so consumed by the issues and difficulties surrounding them — whether within the Church or in the broader world — that they fail to recognize the myriad ways God is actively at work in their lives. This oversight can stifle hope and lead to a sense of paralysis and despair.
As spiritual leaders, priests must take on the role of witnesses to God’s ongoing works. This may involve pointing out the miracles that often remain hidden in plain sight. Too often, we fail to share stories of answered prayers, celebrate moments of grace and remind people of the blessings present in their midst. Parish life provides countless opportunities to remind individuals that God remains active in their lives, regardless of their circumstances.
Particularly during the Jubilee Year, there are fresh opportunities for priests to draw attention to divine action. Pilgrimages, personal conversions, acts of healing and gifts of selfless service are all manifestations of God’s ongoing work in the world. These real experiences of grace serve as powerful reminders that hope is not a distant concept; it is happening right now. When individuals can see evidence of God’s actions, hope begins to flourish.
2. Help people find God in their suffering: It is often said that pain can obscure one’s vision, leading many to equate suffering with the absence of God. However, the priest of hope understands that pain does not imply God’s distance. In many instances, it is within the very depths of suffering that God’s presence is most profoundly felt. Many parishioners, however, do not recognize this, equating hardship with abandonment. This misconception can lead to a loss of both peace and perspective.
The role of the priest is to assist individuals in reinterpreting their suffering — not to justify it but to encounter the Lord within it. By emphasizing that Christ is close to those who suffer, and using the example of the Cross, priests can help their congregation see suffering as an opportunity for divine companionship rather than a signal of divine silence. When parishioners begin to view their trials through this lens, hope can blossom anew.
3. Keep the end in mind: It is essential to recognize that our ultimate destiny encompasses more than earthly aspirations such as retirement, parish success or personal happiness. Rather, our ultimate goal is eternal life. When we lose sight of heaven, our earthly existence can become disorienting and fraught with confusion. As the saying goes, “If you don’t know where you’re going, it’s easy to get lost along the way.”
Priests must guide their flock in recovering a transcendent imagination — a theological perspective that sees beyond the immediate and the temporary. This understanding is not escapism; rather, it provides clarity and context. When heaven is illuminated in our sights, the trials and challenges of life are placed in perspective, and life’s victories are more appropriately appreciated. By reminding people that “this too shall pass” and that something greater awaits us, priests can offer their congregants the strength and encouragement they need to persevere through life’s tribulations.
Ultimately, by providing reasons for hope, priests can empower their parishioners to navigate the complexities of life with faith, resilience and a renewed sense of purpose.
Preach Hope with Intentionality
The ambo can serve as a launching pad for hope. Since preaching is the primary way that most Catholics hear the voice of the Church, it must also be one of the main avenues through which they encounter hope. This requires three specific practices.
1. Discern what God wants you to say: It’s easy to become too familiar with the Lectionary. The same cycle of readings every three years can lead to a temptation to reuse or recycle content. However, the Holy Spirit is not repetitive — he is always conveying something new. For priests to preach with hope, they must ask the Lord, “What do you want me to say to your people this week?”
This discernment should not be rushed. It requires prayer, listening and openness. A homily becomes hopeful not merely through polish but through inspiration, which comes from intimacy with the Lord.
2. Recommit to the art of homily preparation: Hopeful preaching is not accidental. It is the result of intention, and intention takes time. In an age where priests are often stretched thin and exhausted, preparing a homily can easily become an afterthought. However, it is too important for that.
To provide people with hope, we must recommit to the craft of homily preparation through study, silence, outlining, editing and prayer. Preparation is not a luxury; it is a necessity. Carving out time for intentional thought can be the difference between a generic reflection and a prophetic message.
3. Talk about hope — frequently: Ultimately, we must actively promote the message of hope. Not just once or vaguely, but repeatedly and explicitly. An old communication adage states that people need to hear something seven times before truly remembering it; the same applies to hope. The more often they hear it, the more they will believe it.
Hope can be proclaimed through Scripture, personal testimonies, historical witnesses and daily life experiences. However, it must be explicitly proclaimed. The pulpit should not only diagnose problems; it must also point to solutions, highlight the promises of Christ, emphasize the presence of the Holy Spirit and celebrate the power of the Resurrection.
Our Great Responsibility
“Much will be required of the person entrusted with much” (Lk 12:48). These words of Our Lord are not a warning; they are an invitation. As priests, we have indeed been given much: the grace of ordination, the power to celebrate the sacraments, the privilege of preaching the word, and the sacred identity of standing in persona Christi capitis — in the very person of Christ the Head. Our role is not simply a title; it is a profound mystery that comes with immense dignity and great responsibility.
Among the many responsibilities entrusted to us as priests, perhaps the most urgent in our time is the call to be messengers of hope. In a world marked by fear, confusion, cynicism and spiritual fatigue, the voice of Christ must be heard once again — and that voice must come through us. His voice is not one of panic or despair, but of calm authority. It reassures the sinner with mercy, comforts the mourner, and offers the doubter a foundation of truth. It is the voice of hope.
In this era, when both the world and the Church feel the weight of division and disillusionment, hope is not a luxury; it is a necessity. It is our sacred charge to proclaim this hope. We have been given much and entrusted with Christ himself. Therefore, we must speak not our own words but his.
May the Lord who called us to the priesthood renew our hearts with zeal and conviction. May he anoint our voices to echo his message. And may he make us, in this Jubilee Year and always, living icons of his hope.
FATHER MARK TOUPS is the pastor of Our Lady of the Isle Parish in Grand Isle, Louisiana. He is also a co-founder of the Ministry for Priestly Support and has over 21 years of experience working with priests and seminarians in both internal and external forums. He is an eight-time award-winning author of 15 books and video resources.
